Class 4 is the highest shingle impact-resistance rating, but it isn’t automatically the best choice for every roof. In a comparison of CertainTeed and Malarkey shingles for hail resistance, the specific shingle model matters: Malarkey products range from Class 3 to Class 4, and select CertainTeed models offer Class 4 impact resistance. In hail-prone areas, an impact-resistant option may be worth considering, but the rating is only one part of the decision.
It makes sense to weigh hail resistance against cost and overall roof performance. This comparison explains how impact-resistance ratings work and what to consider when comparing CertainTeed Landmark with Malarkey Legacy. You’ll also see why wind performance and installation matter, and how to decide whether a higher-rated shingle suits your home and local weather risks. A brand name or rating is not a guarantee against storm damage.
Key Takeaways
- Learn what steel-ball impact testing can tell you about a shingle, and where a test rating has limits.
- Compare Landmark and Legacy by construction and roof performance, not brand name alone.
- See why an impact-resistant rating may matter for insurance, while discounts depend on the policy.
- Understand how installation and roof conditions influence performance, and when an inspection can help guide your next step.
Table of Contents
Are impact-resistant shingles worth it?
Impact-resistant shingles can make sense in hail-prone climates, but the rating matters more than the brand alone. The UL 2218 standard, developed in 1996, classifies impact resistance from Class 1 to Class 4. Class 4 is the highest rating. Testing uses steel balls dropped onto shingle samples to assess impact damage. The class indicates how a product performed under test conditions, not that a roof is immune to hail.
Malarkey ratings vary by product line. Vista is rated Class 4, while Highlander is rated Class 3. Select CertainTeed models also offer Class 4 impact resistance. Standard asphalt shingles may have lower impact ratings, so compare the exact product rather than assuming every shingle from one manufacturer performs alike.
Wind performance also depends on the product and how crews install it. CertainTeed Landmark PRO has a standard wind rating of 110 MPH, rising to 130 MPH with the Integrity System. Malarkey Vista is rated for 130 mph winds. Malarkey shingles can reach wind ratings up to 130 mph with proper installation. Required nail count, placement, starter strips, and ridge products affect the stated rating and warranty terms. CertainTeed Landmark shingles have a 15-year wind warranty.
| Shingle option | Impact rating | Wind information |
|---|---|---|
| Malarkey Vista | Class 4 | 130 mph |
| Malarkey Highlander | Class 3 | Product-specific |
| CertainTeed Landmark PRO | Select CertainTeed models offer Class 4 | 110 MPH standard; 130 MPH with Integrity System |
| Standard asphalt shingles | Varies by product | Varies by product |
Hail can damage asphalt shingles without leaving obvious marks. An inspection looks for bruising, cracks, displaced granules, and related signs across the roof, as well as evidence in the gutters. Compare products by their tested impact class, wind requirements, installation system, and warranty, then consider how each fits your climate and roof.
CertainTeed Landmark and Malarkey Legacy comparison
CertainTeed Landmark and Malarkey Legacy differ in construction, but hail performance depends on each model’s impact rating. Malarkey shingles use SBS-modified asphalt, a rubberized polymer that improves flexibility and granule retention. CertainTeed shingles are described as thicker, with more asphalt per square, strong granule adhesion, and UV resistance. These features provide useful context, but they don’t establish that Landmark and Legacy have the same impact rating.
A contractor reported that a Malarkey Vista roof had no visible hail blemishes after a storm with 2-inch hail and 70 mph winds. That account offers a real-world example, not a product-wide result for Vista or Legacy. Homeowners comparing Landmark and Legacy should distinguish a field report from a tested rating and consider the roof’s condition after a storm.
For US model choices, the comparison here centers on CertainTeed Landmark and Malarkey Legacy. Other named CertainTeed lines include Landmark PRO, Presidential Shake, and Belmont; Malarkey examples include Vista and Highlander. CertainTeed Belmont has a slate-look profile and approximately 14 color options. The lines differ, so a rating or feature associated with Vista, Highlander, or Belmont shouldn’t automatically be assigned to Landmark or Legacy.
There isn’t one per-square price difference for Class 4 shingles across these brands. Installed cost depends on the selected model, roof area, tear-off needs, deck condition, underlayment, and installation scope. A discount from an insurer, if offered, is separate from the shingle’s price and performance. Compare written project estimates with matching work scopes to understand the difference.
For a practical comparison, line up the exact model, impact rating, warranty terms, and installation details. Then weigh those factors against the roof’s exposure and household priorities. A roof replacement plan also considers drainage; gutter installation can be part of directing runoff away from the home.

Class 4 shingles and possible insurance discounts
A Class 4 rating can matter beyond hail performance because some insurers offer premium discounts for impact-resistant roofing. The benefit depends on the insurer’s policy and how it recognizes the specific shingle and roof installation. A higher rating alone doesn’t set the discount or guarantee that a policy qualifies.
CertainTeed Belmont IR shingles are rated Class 4 for impact resistance and Class A for fire resistance. CertainTeed also offers Class 4 impact resistance on select models, so the manufacturer and model name matter. Don’t assume every Landmark product carries that rating. Malarkey Vista is another Class 4 example, while Malarkey’s product ratings vary by line.
For insurance, match the installed product to your insurer’s eligibility criteria. Keep product identification and installation records with your roof paperwork so you can document which shingle was installed if supporting details are requested. Policy terms determine whether an enhanced premium discount applies and whether it continues after renewal.
- Identify the product: Record the exact CertainTeed or Malarkey line and model.
- Document the roof: Retain installation records that identify the shingles used.
- Review the policy: Compare the insurer’s impact-resistant roofing criteria with the product documentation.
A report gives potential annual home insurance savings of 5% to 35% from upgrading roofing. Treat that range as a reported estimate, not a promised discount for every homeowner or a specific policy. Ask how the insurer defines eligible materials and what documents it requires. Granules, modified asphalt, and other manufacturer features can distinguish shingles, but they don’t replace the policy’s eligibility rules.
The practical choice is to weigh the added roofing expense against local hail exposure and any available insurance benefit. CertainTeed Belmont IR and Malarkey Vista provide named Class 4 examples, while Landmark eligibility depends on the specific model.
Factors besides shingle brand that affect roof performance
A shingle’s material is only one part of roof performance. Malarkey uses SBS-modified asphalt, a rubberized polymer that supports flexibility, impact resistance, and granule retention. Its NEX asphalt also incorporates recycled tire rubber and plastic. These material features matter, but installation quality and roof deck condition also affect durability over time.
CertainTeed shingles are described as thicker, with more asphalt per square, strong granule adhesion, and UV resistance. These construction features can affect how shingles respond to sunlight and wear. But not every CertainTeed model is identical, and factors such as roof ventilation, existing damage, and severe-weather exposure still matter.
In Tulsa, sun exposure and storms are practical factors when evaluating a roof. Slopes can weather differently depending on their orientation, shade, and exposure. A roof inspection can identify uneven wear, loose or damaged shingles, and concerns around roof details before you choose between products such as Landmark and Legacy.
- Ventilation: Airflow through the roof system is one condition to assess when considering overall performance.
- Sun exposure: Compare shaded and exposed slopes for differences in wear and surface condition.
- Storm history: Hail and wind can affect individual areas even when the roof uses one shingle brand.
- Installation: Fastener placement and compatible starter and ridge products contribute to proper system performance.
Compare architectural shingles by their exact product line, materials, installation details, and warranty terms. Don’t judge Malarkey Legacy and CertainTeed Landmark by brand alone, or assume they share features with other product lines. Roof deck condition and local weather exposure also help guide a sound material choice.
A roof inspection can assess wear, storm effects, and installation concerns together. If you’re weighing these factors for your home, arrange a roof inspection to better understand the roof’s condition.
Rescue Roofing Tulsa
Rescue Roofing Tulsa can help turn a shingle comparison into a roof-specific decision. After hail, a roof inspection assesses visible damage and overall condition, helping clarify whether repair or replacement is the appropriate next step. The choice between CertainTeed and Malarkey matters most when it fits the roof’s needs, installation details, and local weather exposure.
If damage is limited, roof repair may address the affected areas. If the roof needs a broader update, residential or commercial roof replacement can move the project forward. The right option depends on the roof’s condition, not just the shingle label or impact rating.
Contact Rescue Roofing Tulsa to discuss your roof and the options that fit its condition.
Make a roof decision that fits your plans
Choosing shingles is also an opportunity to plan for future roof care. Before moving ahead, note what matters most to your household, such as addressing storm-related concerns, planning for replacement, or understanding the roof’s current condition. That gives the next conversation a practical focus beyond brand preference.
Choosing between CertainTeed and Malarkey shingles for hail resistance is one part of the decision. The next step is to match your priorities to the roof’s actual needs and the work required. A measured approach can help you prepare, whether you’re planning ahead or responding to recent weather.
Contact Rescue Roofing Tulsa for roof advice, and take the next step with confidence.
Frequently Asked Questions
How do CertainTeed and Malarkey shingles compare in hail resistance?
Both manufacturers offer shingles with impact-resistant ratings, but performance depends on the exact product line. For example, Malarkey Vista is Class 4, while Highlander is Class 3; select CertainTeed models also carry Class 4 ratings. For a specific roof, compare the model’s rating and installation requirements rather than treating the brand name as a measure of hail protection.
What are the UL 2218 Class 4 hail test requirements and limitations?
UL 2218 evaluates shingle impact resistance by dropping steel balls onto samples, then assigning a class from 1 to 4. Class 4 is the highest rating. The test compares performance under its test conditions; it doesn’t establish that a roof will avoid damage in every hailstorm. Actual outcomes also depend on the storm and the roof’s condition.
What hail-resistant shingle warranties do CertainTeed and Malarkey offer?
Warranty terms depend on the manufacturer, product, and coverage selected. Read the warranty for the specific CertainTeed or Malarkey shingle being installed, including what it covers and any conditions. Keep product and installation paperwork together. This makes it easier to distinguish shingle coverage from other roof protections when reviewing documents or discussing a future claim.
Do CertainTeed or Malarkey warranties cover hail damage or exclude it?
There’s no reliable blanket answer for every CertainTeed or Malarkey shingle: coverage depends on the specific warranty language and circumstances. A warranty and an insurance policy are different documents, so don’t assume a product warranty covers storm damage. After hail, the roof’s condition, the cause of damage, and applicable policy terms matter to an insurance claim.
What roof installation details affect the hail resistance of CertainTeed and Malarkey shingles?
Installation quality affects roof performance, even when shingles have a strong impact rating. Fastener type, count, and placement must follow the product’s installation instructions; starter and ridge components must also match the roofing system. Incorrect nailing, for example, can affect wind performance and warranty conditions. A sound roof deck and proper installation help shingles function as intended.